A slow cooker pot filled with a creamy herb chicken dish, the kind of recipe where a tarragon substitute works well

Tarragon Substitute: The Best Swaps for Every Recipe

You are halfway through a recipe when you realize the tarragon is missing. Maybe the store was out, or maybe you simply forgot it. A good tarragon substitute can save the dish, but tarragon has a distinctive flavor, and not every herb will do. In this guide, you will learn what tarragon tastes like, the ten best substitutes ranked by how close they come, which swap works best for chicken, fish, sauces and dressings, and how much to use so your dish still tastes right.

What Does Tarragon Taste Like?

Tarragon is a leafy green herb with a flavor unlike any other common herb. Its dominant note is a gentle anise or licorice flavor, similar to fennel but softer, layered with hints of mint, vanilla and pepper. French tarragon, the variety used in cooking, is more aromatic and complex than Russian tarragon, which is hardier but blander and slightly bitter. When a recipe calls for tarragon, it usually means French tarragon.

Tarragon is a classic herb in French cooking. It is the signature flavor of bearnaise sauce, it seasons roast chicken beautifully, and it adds a subtle sweetness to fish, eggs and creamy dressings. Because its anise note is so distinctive, the best tarragon substitute is one that supplies a similar sweetness and licorice hint, rather than one that simply adds generic green herb flavor.

The Best Tarragon Substitutes at a Glance

Substitute Closest match for Use the same amount?
Fennel fronds Fresh tarragon in salads and fish Yes, 1 to 1
Chervil Sauces and eggs Yes, 1 to 1
Basil Chicken and tomato dishes Yes, 1 to 1
Dill Fish and creamy dressings Use a little less
Anise or fennel seed Dried tarragon in cooked dishes Use a pinch only
Marjoram Roast chicken and stews Yes, 1 to 1
Oregano Hearty cooked dishes Use half the amount
Thyme Soups and roasts Yes, 1 to 1
Mint Salads and light sauces Use half the amount
Herbes de Provence Roasts and grilled meats Yes, 1 to 1

10 Best Tarragon Substitutes

1. Fennel fronds

Fennel fronds are the feathery green tops of a fennel bulb, and they are the closest match to fresh tarragon. They share tarragon’s mild anise flavor, and their delicate texture works the same way in salads, fish dishes and garnishes. Use them in a one-to-one ratio. If you buy fennel for another recipe, save the fronds: they are often thrown away, but they are one of the best tarragon substitutes you can find.

2. Chervil

Chervil is a French herb with a mild anise flavor and a hint of parsley. It is a traditional ingredient in fines herbes, the classic French herb blend, and it behaves much like tarragon in sauces, egg dishes and light soups. Chervil is delicate, so add it at the end of cooking, just as you would with fresh tarragon. Use the same amount the recipe calls for.

3. Basil

Basil is the easiest tarragon substitute to find, and it works well in many of the same dishes. It shares tarragon’s sweet, slightly peppery character, though it lacks the anise note. Basil is a good choice for chicken, tomato dishes and pasta, and it is excellent in dressings. Use it fresh, in the same quantity as the tarragon, and expect a slightly sweeter, less licorice-like result.

4. Dill

Dill has a fresh, grassy flavor with a hint of anise, which makes it a natural stand-in for tarragon in fish dishes, creamy dressings and potato salads. It is stronger and more assertive than tarragon, so start with about three quarters of the amount the recipe calls for and taste before adding more. Dill is especially good with salmon, shrimp and cucumber salads.

5. Anise seed or fennel seed

When a recipe calls for dried tarragon, a tiny pinch of anise seed or fennel seed can supply the missing licorice note. These seeds are much stronger than tarragon leaves, so use them sparingly: about one eighth of a teaspoon of seeds for every teaspoon of dried tarragon. Crush the seeds lightly before adding them, and give them time to soften in the dish.

6. Marjoram

Marjoram is sweet, mild and slightly floral, and it works beautifully in the savory dishes where tarragon usually appears, especially roast chicken and stews. It has no anise flavor, but its gentle sweetness fills a similar role. Use it in the same amount as the tarragon, fresh or dried. If you have marjoram and a pinch of fennel seed, combining them comes even closer to tarragon.

7. Oregano

Oregano is bolder and more peppery than tarragon, so it changes the character of a dish more than the other substitutes on this list. It still works in hearty cooked dishes such as braised chicken, tomato sauces and roasted vegetables. Use about half the amount of tarragon the recipe calls for, and avoid it in delicate sauces such as bearnaise, where its strong flavor would take over.

8. Thyme

Thyme is earthy and slightly minty rather than sweet, but it is a reliable substitute in soups, roasts and stews, where its flavor blends into the background. It does not mimic tarragon’s anise note, yet it gives a dish the same kind of herbal depth. Use it in a one-to-one ratio, and prefer fresh thyme when the recipe calls for fresh tarragon.

9. Mint

Mint is a surprising but useful tarragon substitute in salads, light sauces and fruit dishes, because it shares tarragon’s cool, sweet edge. It is much stronger than tarragon, so use about half the amount and chop it finely. Mint works best where tarragon’s fresh, bright side matters most, and it is a good choice for spring salads and yogurt dressings.

10. Herbes de Provence

Herbes de Provence is a blend of thyme, rosemary, oregano, marjoram and sometimes lavender, and tarragon is often part of the mix in traditional versions. The blend gives you a rounded, savory flavor that suits roasts and grilled meats very well. Use it in the same amount as the tarragon, and remember that the lavender in some blends can add a floral note that tarragon does not have.

Which Tarragon Substitute Works Best by Dish?

The best swap depends on what you are cooking.

Chicken

For roast or grilled chicken, basil, marjoram or herbes de Provence are the best choices. They give the same warm, savory flavor, and they hold up to heat. A tarragon butter is a classic finish for grilled meats, and it works just as well with basil or marjoram. For a richer option, serve the chicken with a compound butter made from one of these herbs. If you are grilling beef instead, a tarragon-style herb butter is also wonderful over a sliced tritip, where the anise notes of fennel fronds work especially well.

Fish and seafood

For fish, fennel fronds and dill are the best tarragon substitutes. Both have the light, fresh character that suits salmon, cod, shrimp and scallops, and both work in creamy sauces for fish. Use them fresh and add them late in cooking so their delicate flavor survives.

Sauces, especially bearnaise

Bearnaise sauce is the hardest dish to substitute in, because tarragon is its defining flavor. Chervil comes closest, and a small amount of fennel frond or a pinch of anise seed can help. If you use basil or dill in bearnaise, the sauce will taste good but it will not taste like bearnaise. For this sauce, it is worth buying real tarragon if you can.

Dressings and salads

For salad dressings and green salads, fennel fronds, basil and mint all work well. Try a tarragon-style dressing on a salad with grilled cheese: crumbled halloumi with fresh basil or mint makes a simple, satisfying lunch. Dill is the right choice for creamy dressings, coleslaw and potato salad.

Eggs

For omelets, frittatas and egg salad, chervil and dill are the best substitutes. Both are gentle enough for eggs, and both add the fresh, green flavor that tarragon brings. Add them at the end of cooking so they stay bright.

How Much Substitute Should You Use?

As a general rule, substitute fresh herbs for fresh tarragon in equal amounts, and dried herbs for dried tarragon in equal amounts. When you switch between fresh and dried, remember the standard conversion: one teaspoon of a dried herb equals one tablespoon of the fresh herb.

The exceptions are the strong-flavored substitutes. Use half as much oregano, mint or dill as the tarragon called for, and use only a pinch of anise or fennel seed. Whatever you choose, taste the dish before serving and adjust. You can always add more of a substitute, but you cannot take it out, so start small when you are unsure.

When No Substitute Will Do

Some recipes depend on tarragon so heavily that no substitute is truly satisfying. Bearnaise sauce is the clearest example, and tarragon chicken where the herb is the star of the dish is another. In these cases, it is better to buy tarragon or choose a different recipe. Dried tarragon is also worth keeping in your pantry: it lasts for months and it is a better stand-in for fresh tarragon than most other herbs. And if you have leftover herb chicken, it makes excellent wraps for lunch; if you want to keep the wraps on hand, read our guide on whether you can freeze tortillas so they stay fresh.

How to Store Tarragon and Its Substitutes

Fresh tarragon keeps for about one to two weeks in the refrigerator when wrapped in a damp paper towel inside a bag. Dried tarragon lasts six months to a year in an airtight jar in a cool, dark cupboard. Most of the fresh substitutes on this list, including basil, dill and mint, keep for about a week in the fridge, and they freeze well: chop them, pack them into ice cube trays with a little water or oil, and freeze them for use in cooked dishes. Freezing does not work well for garnishes, but it is perfect for soups, sauces and stews.

Frequently Asked Questions About Tarragon Substitutes

What is the best tarragon substitute overall?

Fennel fronds are the best all-round substitute for fresh tarragon because they share its mild anise flavor and delicate texture. For dried tarragon, a pinch of anise seed or fennel seed comes closest. If you cannot find either, chervil is the next best choice.

Can I use basil instead of tarragon?

Yes, basil is one of the easiest and most reliable tarragon substitutes. It works well in chicken dishes, tomato sauces, pasta and dressings. It is sweeter and lacks tarragon’s licorice note, but in most everyday recipes the difference is small.

Can I use dried herbs instead of fresh tarragon?

Yes. Use one teaspoon of a dried herb for every tablespoon of fresh tarragon. Dried basil, dried dill and dried marjoram all work, but dried herbs should be added earlier in cooking so they have time to soften and release their flavor.

Is there a substitute for tarragon in bearnaise sauce?

Chervil is the closest substitute for tarragon in bearnaise sauce, and a little fennel frond can help. No substitute will taste exactly like tarragon bearnaise, because tarragon defines the sauce. If the sauce matters, buy fresh tarragon.

What does tarragon taste like?

Tarragon tastes mildly like anise or licorice, with hints of mint, vanilla and pepper. French tarragon, the culinary variety, is more aromatic and complex than Russian tarragon, which is milder and slightly bitter. Its flavor is sweet and warm rather than sharp.

Conclusion

Running out of tarragon does not have to ruin dinner. Fennel fronds and chervil come closest to the real thing, basil and dill cover most everyday dishes, and a pinch of anise seed can stand in for dried tarragon in cooked recipes. Match the substitute to the dish, start with a little less when the flavor is strong, and taste as you go. Keep a jar of dried tarragon in the pantry for next time, and you will never be caught without it again.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *